Minutes TC 10/03/2005MINUTES OF A REGULAR TOWN COUNCIL MEETING FOR THE
TOWN OF TROPHY CLUB
LOCATION: 100 MUNICIPAL DRIVE, TROPHY CLUB, TEXAS
Monday, October 3,2005
7:00 P.M.
STATE OF TEXAS 0
COUNTY OF DENTON 4
The Town Council of the Town of Trophy Club, Texas, met in Regular Session on Monday, October 3, 2005. The meeting
was held within the boundaries of the Town and was open to the public.
TOWN COUNCIL MEMBERS PRESENT:
Nick Sanders
Pam Cates
Scott Spence
Beverly Foley
Roger Williams
TOWN COUNCIL MEMBERS ABSENT:
Susan Edstrom
STAFF AND GUEST(S) PRESENT:
Roger Unger
Lisa Ramsey
Beth Ann Gregory
Patricia Adams
Mike Pastor
Adam Adams
Randy Briggs
Mayor
Mayor Pro Tem
Council Member
Council Member
Council Member
Council Member
Assistant Town Manager/Finance Director
Town Secretary
Community Development Manager
Town Attorney
1S Manager
Parks and Recreation Director
Police and Fire Services Director
A. 1 Call to order and announce a quorum.
Mayor Sanders called the Regular Session to order at 7:00 p.m. noting a quorum was present.
A.2 Invocation.
Mayor Sanders gave the invocation.
A.3 Pledge of allegiance to the American Flag.
Pledge of allegiance to the Texas Flag.
"Honor the Texas flag, I pledge allegiance to thee, Texas one and indivisible."
Assistant Town Manager/Finance Director, Roger Unger led the pledges.
A.4 Town Manager Report and Discussion Regarding Project Updates as Listed Below: There will be no action taken
regarding any individual project posted under this item and discussion will be limited. If extensive discussion is
required, the item may be placed on a future agenda.
Administration:
EDC 4B Opening
The Town Council is accepting applications for one opening on EDC 4B. Applications will be accepted
beginning Wednesday, September 28 through Wednesday, October 5". Applications received after the deadline
will not be considered. For more information go to: www.ci.trophyclub.tx.us.
TML Annual Meeting
The annual meeting of the Texas Municipal League (TML) is being held at the Gaylord Texan Resort on
th October 26 through October 29th. This is an opportunity to network with other elected officials, State
Officials, vendors and staff from cities all over Texas. There are several breakout training session that appear to
hold potential benefit to Trophy Club. If you would like to attend any portion of this event please contact Lisa
for more information: lramsey@ci.trophyclub.tx,us.
Finance:
Audit Services Update
We are putting the final touches on the letter of engagement with the firm of Weaver and Tidwell for audit
services. We have already begun compiling the data they will need to begin the audit.
Community Development:
Road Construction
The first half of Shields Court has been paved. The remaining side will be paved this week with driveways and
cleanup to follow in the next two weeks. The stabilization process has begun on Indian Creek with paving to
begin next week dependent on weather.
Administration Building Addition
The grading has begun for the additional parking. We expect to have it available for parking on the 20th, at
which time demolition of the existing parking lot will begin for the construction of the new building.
Police and Fire Services
Police Services Bureau
Currently seeking new Reserves Officers.
DPS will be sponsoring a booth at the Fall Festival. The Department will be providing information on crime
prevention, block parties and gunlocks.
Director Briggs attended the International Assoc. of Police Chiefs in Miami last week and was selected to
participate the worldwide committee for Public Safety Directors.
Fire Services Bureau
The EMS Division of the Fire Department has been awarded funding for RAC (Regional Advisory Committee)
funded by State Trauma, in the amount of $1,234.56.
Special Events:
Fall Festival scheduled for Saturday, October 15
Festival Pictures
Craft Vendors to include:
FundraiserIChildren's Games
Food and Beverage
Entertainment to include: Karaoke Jack, Farmer Brown Petting Zoo, Rock Climbing Wall, inflatables, Clown
animal, Care Flight helicopter. A1 Singleton, Dallas Cowboy linebacker and resident of Trophy Club.
Assistant Town ManagerFinance Director, Roger Unger advised that an update will be provided at the October 17, 2005
Town Council meeting on the DR Horton zoning submittal received by staff on September 14', as well as a possible EDC 4A
grant for structural and fence improvements at Beck Field.
B.l Citizen presentations: this is an opportunity for citizens to address the Council on any matter whether or not it is
posted on the agenda. The Council is not permitted to take action on or discuss any presentations made to the
Council at this time concerning an item not listed on the agenda. The Council will hear presentations on specific
agenda items prior to the Council addressing those items.
No citizen comments.
TOWN COUNCIL CONVENED INTO REGULAR SESSION
*REGULAR SESSION
D.l Discuss and take appropriate action by Resolution to appoint one candidate to the Planning and Zoning Commission.
Council member Williams made a motion to appoint Damian Olthoff to the P & Z Commission; Council member Foley
seconded the motion. Mayor Sanders introduced P & Z Vice Chairman, James Stephens who was present in Chairman Gene
Hill's absence. The floor was opened for discussion. Council Member Williams stated that he was upset to see a resignation
so soon after the contention problems created with the last appointment process. Mayor Pro Tem Cates stated that
precedence was set after the last P & Z appoint process when Council decided that they would take the recommendation
provided by the Commission's Chairman, as well as give first consideration to an applicant that had previously served on the
Board. Council member Williams was uncertain as to whether candidate, Robert Ashby, former P & Z member could
commit to weekly meetings if deemed necessary with the potential development, as he previously resigned from the
Commission due to professional and personal time constraints.
Mayor Pro Tern Cates asked Mr. Ashby if he would be able to affirm his commitment to the meeting schedules involved with
this seat. Mr. Ashby advised that currently, both professional and personally, he would be able to commit to the limitations
as set forth for this seat; however, he is unable to foresee the future. Vice Chairman Stevens spoke to Chairman Hill's
recommendation, verifying that after Chairman Hill interviewed all five candidates and carefully reviewed the candidate's
resumes and community involvement, Chairman Hill's recommendation to Council was Robert Ashby. Council member
Spence stated that he would have to go with Chairman Hill's recommendation as he did not know the candidates personally
and he agreed with the precedence set that the Chairman would make the recommendation. Mayor Sanders read Chairman
Hill's personal evaluation of related experience and skills of both Robert Ashby and Damian Olthoff.
Mayor Pro Tem Cates made a motion to amend William's motion and replace the suggestion of Damian Olthoff with Robert
Ashby, who is the recommendation of the P & Z Commission's Chairman. Council member Spence seconded the motion.
Mayor Sanders called for the vote. Motion to amend tied 2:2, with Council members Williams and Foley voting against the
motion to amend. Mayor Sanders explained that according to the Charter, in the event of a tie, the Mayor would cast a vote.
He advised the Council that we would call for the vote, encouraging the Council to reconsider their vote as to break the tie
themselves. Motion to amend tied 2:2, with Council members Williams and Foley opposing. The Mayor called the vote a
third time, advising that he would be casting his vote. Motion to amend passed 3:2, with Mayor Sanders, Mayor Pro Tem
Cates and Council member Spence voting for and Council members Williams and Foley opposing.
Mayor Sanders called for the vote on the main motion to approve a resolution appointing Robert Ashby to the P & Z
commission. Vote tied 2:2 with Council members Williams and Foley voting against. The Mayor called for the vote
advising that he would cast his vote. Motion passed 3:2 with Mayor Sanders, Mayor Pro Tem Cates and Council member
Spence voting for and Council members Williams and Foley voting against.
D.2
Council
Discuss and take appropriate action regarding nomination of up to five candidates to serve as on the Board of
Directors for Denton Central Appraisal District.
member Williams made a motion to nominate Pearl Ford and Bob Radder to the Board of Directors for the Denton
Central Appraisal; Council member Spence seconded the motion. The floor was opened for discussion. Motion passed
unanimously without discussion.
Due to technical issues, the Mayor was not informed of a citizen's request to speak to this item until after the vote was called.
The Mayor did allow the resident to speak.
Neil Twomey, 203 Oakmont, Trophy Club, TX - Suggested that Council also consider Pat Carr, who is currently serving his
third year term on the DCAD Appraisal Review Board.
Mayor Sanders informed Mr. Twomey that contact was made with Mr. Carr a few weeks previously and that we understood
that due to his current role of the Appraisal Review Board, he was not interested in being nominated to the Board of
Directors. Mr. Twomey clarified that he spoke with Mr. Carr just this past weekend and he is interested in the Board of
Directors and if elected, he would resign his current position. Council member Spence moved to reconsider motion; Mayor
Pro Tem Cates seconded. Council member Spence moved to amend the motion; nominating Pat Carr in addition to Pearl
Ford and Bob Radder to the DCAD Board of Directors; Mayor Pro Tem Cates seconded. Motion passed unanimously
without further discussion.
D.3 Discuss and take appropriate action regarding a potential pilot program to designate a three quarter mile section of
Trophy Club Drive between Oak Hill and Meadow Creek as one lane with a shoulder to provide traffic calming and
establish an area of the road where normal motor vehicle travel would be prohibited, but parking would be
maintained.
Council member Williams made a motion to approve the pilot project; Council member Spence seconded the motion. The
floor was opened for discussion. Mayor Pro Tem stated that she is concerned with people's safety perception of the traffic
calming and feels that the Town is better off with sidewalks on the major thoroughfares.
Mayor Sanders corrected that the $12,000.00 it would cost to fund this project is not currently in the budget as previously
reported. Staff had intended for this to be voted on prior to the budget being passed, however, due to the delay of the item
coming back before Council, the $12,000.00 is not a line item currently in the budget. Finance Director, Roger Unger
advised that the funding could come out of two sources, either the ongoing street maintenance or the contingency funds,
which is for projects or issues that come up during the course of the year.
Council member Spence spoke that two major issues break from this, sidewalks verses shoulders and that there are many
issues with the shoulders that sidewalks will not fix. Council member Spence spoke in favor of this pilot project, and believe
that it is an attempt to teach people that these are one-lane streets. Council member Williams agreed that this is an attempt to
make people aware that these are one-lane streets and that given the two-month delay already, we should give it a try.
Council member Williams made a motion to approve pilot project for six months and then come back to Council to see if the
residents want a referendum; Council member Foley seconded the motion.
Council member Foley requested that discuss the funding. Council member Williams amended his motion to include that the
funding would come from street maintenance as suggested by Finance Director, Roger Unger; Council member Foley
seconded.
Council member Spence suggested that the residents drive with the pilot project and still vote on it in the May election.
Council member Williams made a motion to amend his motion to approve the pilot project for six months, with funding
taken from street maintenance and including as a referendum on the ballots in May, assuming that all can be accomplished
with election deadlines; Council member Foley seconded.
Margi Cantrell, 1105 Sunset, spoke in favor of the pilot project.
Bob Radder, 1 Lee Court, spoke in favor of traffic calming and stated that this does not need to be put to a referendum, but
rather, Council should make a permanent decision now.
Doyle Krauss, 549 Indian Creek, spoke in favor of the pilot project.
Bob Downey, 531 Indian Creek, encouraged Council to vote in favor of the pilot project.
Community Development Director, Beth Ann Gregory confirmed Mayor Sander's question that signage is included in the
$12,000.00 cost.
Council member Spence spoke to the controversy surrounding this issue; stating that this issue is too big for the Council to
make a decision on and felt that it should be left up to the democracy of the people.
Council member Williams believes that signage informing drivers of the one-lane streets would be beneficial in other areas of
the Town.
Mayor Pro Tem Cates commented that calming the roads might make the roads safer, but just because there is calming on the
roads, people should not feel confident that they would be safe on the road.
Mayor Sanders called for the vote. Motion to approve the traffic calming project for the section of Trophy Club Drive for six
months, with funding taken from street maintenance and with Council including as a referendum on the ballots in May,
assuming that this can be accomplished with election time deadlines, passed unanimously without further discussion.
D.4 Discuss and receive direction regarding charging fees for the use of the pool and other facilities.
Parks and Recreation Director, Adam Adams informed Council that there are three types of fees; association fees, fees for
facility usage and fees for tournaments. He spoke to the results of the survey which concluded that the smaller the city, the
less likely it was to charge fees of any type, less likely to have good facilities and as many facilities with the same standards
to the ones in the Town. Most cities have a co-sponsored agreement with the associations, which is currently what Trophy
Club has in place; where the associations are immune from fees, providing they participate in the upkeep of the fields.
Mr. Adams answered Council member Williams question that Roanoke does has pool passes, but does not have association
fees. Council discussed that most cities do have pool fees and some type of association fees, and that if the Town did
approve fees they would need to applied fairly across the board.
Mr. Adams acknowledged Mayor Pro Tem Cates concern over the lighting cost and explained that EDC will be reviewing a
break down of the lighting costs as well as speaking to two vendors who may be able to provide lighting solutions. Council
member Spence cautioned that it is difficult trying to develop a fee schedule that works for all the residents.
Council member Williams asked for an agenda item addressing applying fees to the pool and also a discussion of what fees
will be charged. Mr. Adams clarified that he would like to look at the associations and come up with a dollar amount on their
contributions and man-hours and the bring forward a pool package with resident pool fees; single, family and swim team.
D.5 Discuss and receive direction regarding a future amendment to Ordinance 2004- 17 regulating the operation of motor
assisted scooters.
Police and Fire Services Director, Randy Briggs informed Council that after surveying the originals cities first surveyed when
Ord. 2004- 17 was first passed, it was determined that the other cities have made changes to the regulations and operation of
motor assisted scooters. Chief Briggs asserted that he has concern that kids who are not knowledgeable to the rules of the
road are operating scooters. Mayor Sanders introduced Barb Tweedie, 220 Oakmont, as a member of the Public Safety
Committee who conferred with Chief Briggs and his desire to change the age restrictions so that the individuals are aware of
the rules of the roads.
Discussion ensued about age restrictions according to State Law; and if our officer's should be put in a position of having to
guess the riders age. Chief Briggs advised that the other cities surveyed based their ordinance restriction on street width and
speed.
Mayor Sanders requested that Council summarize the direction they were giving to staff. Council member Williams
requested that staff amend the restrictions to Ordinance 2004-17, and present to Council at the November 7' meeting.
D.6 Discuss and take appropriate action regarding the repeal of Ordinance Nos. 2004-01 & 2004-09 relating to traffic
and street control standards, and adopting a new Ordinance related to traffic and street control standards, with new criteria
specifically related to U-Turns signs.
Director Briggs advised that adding criteria specifically related to U-Turn signs to this Ordinance is a proactive measure. CD
Director, Beth Ann Gregory advised it was a resident's complaint, generated via the Citizen Relationship Management that
prompted the research on U-Turns.
Council member Williams moved to repeal Ordinance 2004-01 & 2004-09 and adopt 2005-26; Council member Spence
seconded motion. Floor opened for discussion.
Mayor Pro Tem Cates requested we communicate this change in the monthly newsletter and on Listserv. Motion to adopt
Ordinance 2005-26, relating to traffic and street control standards, with new criteria specifically related to U-Turns signs,
passed unanimously without further discussion.
Mayor Sanders called on Greg Lamont, 15 Avalon, who spoke in favor of item.
D.7 Discuss and take appropriate action regarding a Resolution approving the 2005-2006 Interlocal Agreement between
the Town and Tarrant Count Hospital District d/b/a JPS Health Network.
Director Briggs explained that this item is an annual agreement and that the Town Attorney requested it be pulled from the
consent agenda. Town Attorney, Patricia Adams counseled that this item was removed from the Consent Agenda, so that she
could advise that certain verbiage be added to the indemnity clause. Ms. Adams continued that she did feel that Tarrant
County Hospital would have a problem with this verbiage.
Council member Williams made a motion to approve the resolution with the amendment to the indemnity clause, to read 'to
the extent allowed by law'; Mayor Pro Tem Cates seconded. Motion passed unanimously without further discussion.
All matters listed as Consent Agenda are considered to be routine by the Town Council and will be enacted by one motion.
There will not be a separate discussion of these items. If discussion is desired, that item will be removed from the consent
agenda and will be considered separately.
Mayor Sanders respected that item D.8 be removed from the Consent Agenda as Council member Spence was not in
attendance. Council member Williams moved to remove item D.8; Council member Foley seconded. Motion passed
unanimously.
D.8
Mayor
Consent Agenda: Discuss and take appropriate action to approve Minutes dated, September 19th, 2005.
Sanders requested advised that item D.5 read: "Council member Williams advised that he thought that sidewalks were
only going to be a consideration if it could be done in conjunction with the current construction; and then confirmed
with Ms. Gregory that it could not. Council member Edstrom withdrew her motion and stated that she
misunderstood that this could be done in conjunction; Mayor Pro Tem Cates agreed with the mover to withdraw the
motion. Motion withdrawn without further discussion."
Council member Williams made a motion to approve the September 19", 2005 minutes as modified; Mayor Pro Tem Cates
seconded. Motion passed 3:O:l with Council member Spence abstaining.
D.9 Consent Agenda - Discuss and take appropriate action to expend Court Technology Funds in the amount of $500 for
travel expenses for Court Training.
Council member Foley made a motion to approve the Consent Agenda as amended, D.9; Council member Williams
seconded. Motion passed unanimously without further discussion.
D.10 Items for Future Agenda.
1. Long term capital project list, projected fiscal impact and surveys for resident input on potential projects.
2. Discussion and appropriate action for Parks and Recreation future plans of Marshall Creek
Parks and Recreation Director, Adam Adams advised that currently proceeding with budget plans from last year.
and suggested the possibility of bringing in a Park Planner as an independent contractor.
3. Status of street repairs and bonds, including recommendation.
Due to current project demands, Community Development, Beth Ann Gregory requested a delay for providing
this status
4. Discussion and appropriate action for an Ordinance to approve vacant land appraisal.
Planning and Zoning Coordinator, Kerin Fleck requested that this item be removed.
5. Discuss and take appropriate action to approve a Resolution authorizing an Economic Development Agreement
with Midwest Commercial Realty. (October 17,2005)
6. Discuss and take appropriate action by Resolution to appoint one candidate to EDC 4B. November 7,2005
7. Discuss and take appropriate action by Resolution, casting all of its allocated votes (16) for (candidates names) to
serve as a member of the Denton Central Appraisal District Board of Directors. November 21st, 2005
8. Discussion and appropriate action of the Town's participation in a program through the America Supporting
Americans program where Towns can adopt an armed services unit and provide them support.
Mayor Sander explained this program and advised that Council would need to pass a resolution for support.
e Mayor Sanders requested, discussion and appropriate action for signage on Indian Creek indicating one lane streets.
e Mayor Pro Tem Cates requested the Public Safety Advisory Group to start researching ways to handle the garage
sale traffic.
Discuss and take appropriate action regarding amendments to the restrictions of Ordinance 2004-17 regulations and
operation of motor assisted scooters. (November 7", 2005)
Evaluate Park fees with consideration to association fees.
Election of a task force, as Suggested by Council member Spence of five to work with the school district on joint
use option. (November 7", 2005)
TOWN COUNCIL TO CONVENE INTO EXECUTIVE SESSION
EXECUTIVE SESSION
Town Council convened into Executive Session at 9: 12 p.m.
E. 1 Pursuant to Texas Government Code, Annotated, Subchapter 55 1, Section 55 1.087 (2) "Deliberation Regarding
Economic Development Negotiations" and Section 551.071 (b) "Consultation with Attorney", the Council will enter
into executive session to discuss the following:
(A) To discuss or deliberate the offer of financial or other incentives to a business prospect that the Town seeks
to have locate within the territory of the Town pursuant to Section 55 1.087 (2) of the Texas Open Meetings
Act and For Consultation with the Town Attorney on a matter in which the duty of the Attorney to the
Governmental Body under the Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct of the State Bar of Texas clearly
conflict with the Open Meetings Act ($55 1.07 1 (b)).
(I) Financial and other incentives for the proposed D.R. HortonIBeck Properties mixed use development and
legal advice regarding the proposed development, zoning and platting, potential economic incentives and
contractual agreements, potential contracts for water and wastewater services, traffic impact, ordinance
requirements, and matters related to the proposed development.
TOWN COUNCIL TO RECONVENE INTO REGULAR SESSION
"REGULAR SESSION
Town Council convened inti Regular Session at 10:07 p.m.
E.2 Discuss and take appropriate action relative to Executive Session Item Number El.
No action taken.
F.l Adjourn.
Mayor Pro Tem Cates made a motion to adjourn; Council member Williams seconded.
d.g Town Secretary, Town of T,ophy Club
Mayor, Town of Trophy Club